(305) 814-6671

Welcome to Papa Joe’s of Islamorada

Since its inception, Papa Joe’s of Islamorada has been a beacon of the Florida Keys’ culinary and cultural heritage. Originally founded as Ev Fowler’s Caribee Basin in 1937, the property was reimagined as Papa Joe’s by Joe Miller in 1969. In 1982, the Gehrkens family, led by Mr. and Mrs. George R. Gehrkens, acquired the business and infused it with their passion for authentic, award-winning Florida Keys cuisine.

A Legacy of Culinary Excellence

Under the Gehrkens family, Papa Joe’s gained acclaim, including Zagat recognition for its legendary Seafood Bisque. Despite closing the original Islamorada location in 2006 due to economic challenges and family health issues, the tradition lives on. The family pivoted, bringing Papa Joe’s gourmet offerings to events and festivals across the nation, ensuring that their beloved dishes continue to delight fans of Florida Keys fare.

New Horizons: Florida Keys Life

In addition to gourmet cuisine, Papa Joe’s has expanded its brand with Florida Keys Life, a trademarked apparel line. This collection celebrates the vibrant and relaxed lifestyle of the Keys, featuring everything from beachwear to accessories. Whether it’s a soft hoodie or a classic fishing shirt, Florida Keys Life embodies the spirit of island living.

Setting the Record Straight

It’s important to note that Papa Joe’s of Islamorada is not affiliated with Papa Joe’s Waterfront, a new business operating at our former location. The Gehrkens family retains full ownership of the original Papa Joe’s brand and continues to serve award-winning cuisine under the same high standards. We sincerely apologize for any confusion this may have caused and appreciate your unwavering support as we carry on our family’s legacy.

A Journey Through the Keys

From iconic festivals like the Key West Seafood Festival to the annual Islamorada Sailfish Tournament, the Florida Keys offer a tapestry of experiences. Papa Joe’s is proud to be part of this rich tradition, bringing our culinary excellence to every event. Whether you’re savoring our famous bisque or browsing our Florida Keys Life apparel, we invite you to celebrate the Keys with us.

© Papa Joe’s of Islamorada, Florida Keys is owned and operated by Papa Joe’s of Islamorada LLC. All rights reserved 2014-2025